Tobey Maguire: 10 Best Movies

By Vlad Zakh · April 13, 2026

United States Drama thought provoking

Spider-Man remains the role most people know him for, and the trilogy still holds up as the foundation of the modern superhero genre, while Seabiscuit and The Cider House Rules show a quieter, more restrained side. Brothers returns a presumed-dead soldier home changed, Wonder Boys orbits Michael Douglas’s blocked novelist, The Great Gatsby makes him Nick Carraway, and Babylon adds a supporting role during Hollywood’s transition to sound. Pleasantville and Spider-Man: No Way Home round out the list.

Babylon (2022) 01

Babylon (2022)

IMDb ★ 7.1 RT 57%

Ambitious dreamers deal with the hedonistic excess and brutal transformation of 1920s Hollywood.

Directed by Damien Chazelle · 3h 09m · Rated R

Nominated for 3 Oscars48 wins & 158 nominations

Starring Diego Calva, Margot Robbie, Brad Pitt, Jovan Adepo

More lists like this: Margot Robbie: 10 Best Movies

Wonder Boys (2000) 03

Wonder Boys (2000)

IMDb ★ 7.2 RT 81%

A blocked novelist and creative writing professor navigates personal chaos over one eventful weekend.

MovieIx review: Michael Douglas shuffling around in a bathrobe, stuck on a novel that's past two thousand pages, is a great sad sack. Tobey Maguire as the strange student who lies about everything is funny and touching. When the manuscript pages blow away in the wind, we laughed and felt sad at the same time, and the snowy campus gives it a cozy feel.

Directed by Curtis Hanson · 1h 47m · Rated R

Won 1 Oscar21 wins & 46 nominations

Starring Michael Douglas, Tobey Maguire, Frances McDormand, Robert Downey Jr.

More lists like this: Frances McDormand: 10 Best Movies

The Great Gatsby (2013) 04

The Great Gatsby (2013)

IMDb ★ 7.2 RT 48%

A mysterious, self-made millionaire's lavish parties hide his obsessive pursuit of a lost love.

MovieIx review: We'd rate it higher than critics. DiCaprio's entrance, turning with a glass to "Rhapsody in Blue" and fireworks, is a reveal we've rewatched a dozen times. The parties are wild and gorgeous, even if the hip-hop soundtrack splits people. Luhrmann captures the longing, and the green light ending hurt.

Directed by Baz Luhrmann · 2h 23m · Rated PG-13

Won 2 Oscars51 wins & 86 nominations

Starring Leonardo DiCaprio, Tobey Maguire, Carey Mulligan, Joel Edgerton

More lists like this: Leonardo DiCaprio: 10 Best Movies · Best 20 American Drama Movies

Pleasantville (1998) 05

Pleasantville (1998)

A modern teenager transported into a black-and-white 1950s sitcom world.

Directed by Gary Ross · 2h 04m · Rated PG-13

Starring Tobey Maguire, Reese Witherspoon, William H. Macy, Joan Allen

The Cider House Rules (1999) 06

The Cider House Rules (1999)

IMDb ★ 7.4 RT 72%

An orphan raised by a small-town doctor learns his mentor's trade before venturing out into the world.

MovieIx review: Michael Caine as Dr. Larch saying goodnight to the orphans with "you princes of Maine, you kings of New England" moved us every time he said it. Tobey Maguire is quietly great as Homer. The apple orchard summer is gentle and beautiful, and the darker moral choices give it weight.

Directed by Lasse Hallström · 2h 06m · Rated PG-13

Won 2 Oscars8 wins & 30 nominations

Starring Tobey Maguire, Charlize Theron, Michael Caine, Delroy Lindo

More lists like this: Michael Caine: 10 Best Movies

Seabiscuit (2003) 07

Seabiscuit (2003)

IMDb ★ 7.3 RT 77%

An undersized racehorse becomes an unlikely Depression-era symbol of hope.

MovieIx review: Jeff Bridges, Chris Cooper and Tobey Maguire play three broken men who heal by betting on a broken horse, and that story worked on us. The match race against War Admiral, with the whole country listening on the radio, is thrilling. William H. Macy as the wacky radio announcer is a fun bonus.

Directed by Gary Ross · 2h 21m · Rated PG-13

Nominated for 7 Oscars6 wins & 44 nominations

Starring Tobey Maguire, David McCullough, Jeff Bridges, Chris Cooper

More lists like this: 59 Best Sports Movies Ever Made

Spider-Man: No Way Home (2021) 08

Spider-Man: No Way Home (2021)

IMDb ★ 8.1 RT 93%

A spell gone wrong pulls villains from other universes into Peter Parker's already fractured world.

MovieIx review: Seeing all three Spider-Men together in one frame was a huge payoff for anyone who grew up with these movies. The villains coming back is a lot of fun, especially Willem Dafoe's Goblin. Peter losing Aunt May and choosing to be forgotten by everyone is the saddest Marvel ending.

Directed by Jon Watts · 2h 28m · Rated PG-13

Nominated for 1 Oscar35 wins & 72 nominations

Starring Tom Holland, Zendaya, Benedict Cumberbatch, Jacob Batalon

More lists like this: 8 Best Movies of 2021 · Andrew Garfield: 10 Best Movies · Zendaya: 10 Best Movies

Spider-Man 2 (2004) 09

Spider-Man 2 (2004)

IMDb ★ 7.5 RT 93%

Peter Parker's double life as Spider-Man collides with a new, tragic supervillain.

MovieIx review: The train fight with Doc Ock is the best action scene in any Spider-Man movie for us. When the passengers carry Peter's unmasked body back inside and promise not to tell, we get a lump in our throat. Alfred Molina's villain is tragic, a good man ruined by his own invention.

Directed by Sam Raimi · 2h 07m · Rated PG-13

Won 1 Oscar25 wins & 60 nominations

Starring Tobey Maguire, Kirsten Dunst, James Franco, Alfred Molina

More lists like this: 50 Best Action Movies of All Time · 50 Best Movies of the 2000s · 50 Best Superhero Movies of All Time

Spider-Man (2002) 10

Spider-Man (2002)

IMDb ★ 7.4 RT 90%

The Green Goblin, still one of the more genuinely unhinged superhero-movie villains.

MovieIx review: Willem Dafoe arguing with himself in the mirror as Norman and the Goblin is creepy and kind of brilliant. The upside down kiss in the rain is still our favorite superhero romance moment. Uncle Ben dying in Peter's arms makes the whole story personal, and Raimi gives it so much heart.

Directed by Sam Raimi · 2h 01m · Rated PG-13

Nominated for 2 Oscars17 wins & 65 nominations

Starring Tobey Maguire, Willem Dafoe, Kirsten Dunst, James Franco

More lists like this: Kirsten Dunst: 10 Best Movies · Willem Dafoe: 10 Best Movies · 50 Best Superhero Movies of All Time

Vlad Zakh

Vlad Zakh

Founder, Movieix

Founder of Movieix. He started the site because most recommendation pages felt like noise. Here, lists are sorted by who's in the film, where it's from and what mood you're in tonight.